Damning Senedd verdict accuses WRU of dereliction of duty and says its lost the argument

The WRU’s plans have been slammed by the Senedd

Senedd members have told Welsh Rugby Union chair Richard Collier-Keywood he has “lost the argument” over controversial plans to cut Wales’ professional clubs to three, branding the failure to produce a viable alternative a “dereliction of duty.”

Collier-Keywood appeared before the Senedd’s Culture, Communications, Welsh Language, Sport and International Relations Committee last Thursday alongside the WRU’s community director Geraint John and independent non-executive director Alison Thorne.

The WRU chair defended the decision to cut one of Wales’ four professional clubs and was adamant the governing body had not definitely decided to axe the Ospreys despite Swansea Council saying if Y11 Sports & Media complete a deal to buy Cardiff Rugby this would be the case.

Ensure our latest sport headlines always appear at the top of your Google Search by making us a Preferred Source. Click here to activate or add us as Preferred Source in your Google search settings

In a letter sent to Collier-Keywood from the committee following the hearing, chair Delyth Jewell he accused him of losing the argument.

“We recognise the significant hard work that has been undertaken over the last few years to stabilise the WRU’s financial position, as well as positive developments within the culture of the WRU,” wrote Ms Jewell.

“We also recognise that the WRU and individual leaders are sometimes exposed to criticism that is unduly harsh, especially online.

“However, it is clear to us that Welsh rugby is in a perilous state. Uncertainty surrounding the future of Welsh regions has caused considerable concern to people across our nation.

“No programme of change can be achieved without building a consensus for change.

“It is clear the union does not have consensus needed to move forward with the proposal to reduce the number of regional sides from four to three.

“The WRU must recognise that it has lost the argument over the future of the professional game.”

The WRU has not currently put forward an alternative plan to restructure the professional game.

On top of this Collier-Keywood is facing a vote of no-confidence at a WRU EGM at the conclusion of the Six Nations while the governing body is also locked in a legal dispute with the Scarlets and Swansea Council.

“We were alarmed to hear you tell us that you have no plan B, should your current proposals not progress as planned,” wrote Ms Jewell.

“Were this the case, it could represent a significant dereliction of duty. We urge you to find an alternative approach that continues to stabilise the finances of the Union and maintains confidence, whilst rebuilding trust with clubs and supporters.

“The people of Wales feel a deep sense of ownership, pride and emotional connection to the game.

“That connection must be respected and nurtured. The union must not find itself in the position of winning the vote but losing the soul of Welsh rugby.”